Why 33 US state capitals are not the biggest city in their state

In 33 of the 50 US states the capital is not the largest city. That is a majority, and the pattern is not random. Founders and 19th-century legislators pushed capitals away from crowded ports and toward interior towns for reasons that felt urgent at the time: fear of naval bombardment, distrust of urban political machines, the pull of a river junction near new farmland, or simply the need for a compromise site between rival cities. The 17 states where the capital is also the biggest city are the exceptions, and most of them are Sun Belt boomers whose capital was chosen before anywhere else could challenge it.

The 17 states where the capital IS the largest city

Start with the exceptions. In these 17 states the capital and the largest city are the same:

• Arizona — Phoenix (about 1.6 million residents)
• Arkansas — Little Rock
• Colorado — Denver
• Georgia — Atlanta
• Hawaii — Honolulu
• Idaho — Boise
• Indiana — Indianapolis
• Iowa — Des Moines
• Massachusetts — Boston
• Mississippi — Jackson
• Nebraska — Lincoln (Omaha is close but smaller by city limits)
• North Dakota — Bismarck (largest is actually Fargo, so this is disputed)
• Ohio — Columbus
• Oklahoma — Oklahoma City
• Rhode Island — Providence
• South Carolina — Columbia
• Utah — Salt Lake City
• Wyoming — Cheyenne

Counts vary between 17 and 18 depending on whether you treat Fargo or Bismarck as the largest in North Dakota. The US Census puts Fargo ahead of Bismarck in city population, which is why most modern lists call it 17 states, not 18.

The 33 states where the capital is NOT the biggest city

Here are the 33 mismatches, with the capital and the largest city side by side:

State	Capital	Largest city
Alabama	Montgomery	Huntsville
Alaska	Juneau	Anchorage
California	Sacramento	Los Angeles
Connecticut	Hartford	Bridgeport
Delaware	Dover	Wilmington
Florida	Tallahassee	Jacksonville
Illinois	Springfield	Chicago
Kansas	Topeka	Wichita
Kentucky	Frankfort	Louisville
Louisiana	Baton Rouge	New Orleans
Maine	Augusta	Portland
Maryland	Annapolis	Baltimore
Michigan	Lansing	Detroit
Minnesota	Saint Paul	Minneapolis
Missouri	Jefferson City	Kansas City
Montana	Helena	Billings
Nevada	Carson City	Las Vegas
New Hampshire	Concord	Manchester
New Jersey	Trenton	Newark
New Mexico	Santa Fe	Albuquerque
New York	Albany	New York City
North Carolina	Raleigh	Charlotte
North Dakota	Bismarck	Fargo
Oregon	Salem	Portland
Pennsylvania	Harrisburg	Philadelphia
South Dakota	Pierre	Sioux Falls
Tennessee	Nashville	Nashville (largest, tied)
Texas	Austin	Houston
Vermont	Montpelier	Burlington
Virginia	Richmond	Virginia Beach
Washington	Olympia	Seattle
West Virginia	Charleston	Charleston (largest)
Wisconsin	Madison	Milwaukee

Nashville is a special case. After city-county consolidation with Davidson County it has become the biggest city in Tennessee, overtaking Memphis. Charleston is the largest city in West Virginia by most counts. If you drop those edge cases the strict answer is closer to 31 mismatches. The commonly cited figure of 33 counts them anyway.

Why the founders picked small towns over big ports

The 13 original colonies gave a preview of the pattern. In 1797 New York moved its capital from New York City to Albany. Massachusetts kept Boston, but many other coastal states looked inland. Three reasons come up again and again.

1. Fear of the British Navy

After the Revolution and the War of 1812, a capital on the coast felt exposed. Washington, D.C. itself was burned in 1814. States responded by placing their seats of government away from open water. Trenton, Annapolis and Dover are all near the coast, but tucked inland along rivers. Harrisburg replaced Philadelphia in Pennsylvania in 1812, only months before British forces returned to the Chesapeake.

2. Rural distrust of urban politics

Nineteenth-century state legislatures were dominated by rural districts. Farmers and small-town merchants did not want their laws written inside cities they saw as corrupt. Springfield, Illinois was chosen over Chicago partly because a young lawyer named Abraham Lincoln lobbied for it in 1837. Jefferson City, Missouri was placed at the geographic center of the state rather than at St. Louis. Tallahassee was picked in 1824 because it sat exactly halfway between the two existing regional capitals of Pensacola and St. Augustine.

3. Compromise between rival cities

Where two cities were already fighting for economic dominance, legislators often picked a third neutral site. Lansing was a swampy wilderness when Michigan named it capital in 1847, chosen to end the tug-of-war between Detroit and the west of the state. Frankfort, Kentucky beat both Louisville and Lexington in 1792. Raleigh, North Carolina was laid out from scratch in 1792 as a compromise capital.

The most extreme mismatches

Some pairings are lopsided enough to be startling. Ranked by the population gap between the largest city and the capital:

• New York: New York City has roughly 8.3 million residents, Albany about 100,000. A ratio of 83 to 1.
• Illinois: Chicago at 2.7 million, Springfield at 114,000. A ratio of 24 to 1.
• California: Los Angeles at 3.8 million, Sacramento at 525,000. A ratio of 7 to 1, but Los Angeles is 380 miles from Sacramento.
• Nevada: Las Vegas at 660,000, Carson City at 60,000. A ratio of 11 to 1.
• Florida: Jacksonville at 970,000, Tallahassee at 200,000. Add the metro areas and Miami dwarfs both.
• Vermont: Burlington at 45,000, Montpelier at 8,000. Small numbers, but Montpelier is the smallest state capital in the country.

Capitals that used to be somewhere else

Fifteen states have moved their capital at least once. A few of the more interesting moves:

• New York: New York City (1784-1797), then Albany.
• Pennsylvania: Philadelphia (1683-1799), then Lancaster (1799-1812), then Harrisburg.
• Georgia: Savannah, then Augusta, then Louisville, then Milledgeville, and finally Atlanta in 1868.
• California: San Jose (1850), Vallejo, Benicia, then Sacramento permanently in 1854.
• Alabama: Cahaba, then Tuscaloosa, then Montgomery.
• Ohio: Chillicothe, Zanesville, back to Chillicothe, then Columbus in 1816.

Every relocation reflected some mix of the same three pressures: security, geography, and politics.

Federal capitals also moved

The pattern is not just at the state level. The US national capital moved eight times before settling on Washington, D.C. in 1800. Philadelphia hosted the Continental Congress and the federal government from 1790 to 1800. Before that, New York City served briefly from 1785 to 1790, and towns as small as Trenton, Annapolis, York and Princeton held Congress during the Revolution. The Constitution had to be argued into place before the country could agree on a permanent seat.

Frequently asked questions

Is Washington, D.C. a state capital?

No. Washington, D.C. is the capital of the United States, not of a state. It is a federal district that is not part of any state. Maryland ceded the land in 1790.

Which state capital is the highest above sea level?

Santa Fe, New Mexico, at 7,199 feet (2,194 m). Cheyenne, Wyoming is second at about 6,062 feet. Denver, Colorado is famously the "Mile High City" at 5,280 feet.

Which state capital is the youngest?

Juneau, Alaska. Alaska joined the Union in 1959 and Juneau has been the capital since territorial days. Honolulu is close behind: Hawaii became a state the same year.

Why is Trenton, New Jersey the capital instead of Newark?

Trenton became capital in 1790 as a compromise between the northern and southern halves of the colony. It also sits at the head of navigation on the Delaware River, useful in an era before railroads.

Related guides